difference between cottage pie and shepherd's pie

While cottage pie was made with beef. Where to eat the best Fish and Chips in London and beyond…. In fact, they have even been around for longer than Shepherd’s Pies, recorded to have been around since 1700s. First, the answer to the big question, is that the main difference between Shepherd’s Pie and Cottage Pie is in the meat. Shepherd’s Pie contains lamb and is an Irish specialty. These dishes were made from the leftovers of a Sunday roast. Its the … I grew up in northern England and cottage pie, shepherd’s pie and Cumberland pie are served to you on a regular basis. What is the difference between cottage pie and shepherd's pie? Cottage Pie and Shepherd's Pie are very similar. Traditionally, Shepherd's Pie is made with ground or minced lamb, while a Cottage … Place the potatoes, garlic and salt pot with enough water to cover the potatoes. The straightforward difference between shepherd’s pie and cottage pie is that the former is made with lamb, while the latter is made with beef and/or other ground meats. 1 decade ago. Are you wondering what’s the difference between Shepherd’s Pie and Cottage Pie? Unlike a Shepherd’s Pie that is made from lamb meat, Cottage Pies use beef as the main protein. Cottage pie, also known as shepherd's pie, is a traditional English dish made with minced (ground) meat covered with mashed potato. Shepherd’s Pie is traditionally made with ground lamb while it’s more well-known and oft-mistaken cousin, Cottage Pie, is made with ground beef. When it comes to the ingredients of both dishes, there’s always some hot debate as to which vegetables should be added to the minced meat bases of the pies, especially with peas and carrots. Again, it really is a mystery as to why we use the word ‘pie’ in Britain to name dishes with mashed potato toppings, as well as pastry encased fillings. One of the distinguishing characteristics of Shepherd’s or Cottage pie is that the meat filling is minced fine. eval(ez_write_tag([[728,90],'britishgrubhub_com-box-3','ezslot_14',109,'0','0'])); Can’t see much difference from the pictures? Today it is usually called “cottage pie” if it is made with ground beef and “shepherd’s pie” when it’s made with minced lamb because a shepherd looks after sheep. This Is Probably Why…, The Best British Snacks – 100+ UK Crisps, Cakes, Biscuits, Chocolate Bars and Sweets, How To Cook a Roast Dinner For 10 Or More People…. The straightforward difference between shepherd’s pie and cottage pie is that the former is made with lamb, while the latter is made with beef and/or other ground meats. But more interestingly, many of them had never eaten lamb before. Because the focus of a cottage pie is a poor man’s dinner, the idea is that you use whatever ingredients you have in to bulk it up. Click Here To Read Our Full Disclosure. Easy way to remember, the shepherd looks after the lambs then eats one of them……….. Originally Answered: What is the difference between a cottage pie and a shepherd's pie? But just use whatever meat – and whatever name – you prefer. Let ’ s start with a fairly well-known one: there is a difference between “ Cottage Pie ” and “S hepherd ’ s Pie ”, and it ’ s in the meat. How to Make Creamy Mashed Cauliflower . Shepherd's pie is made with lamb and Cottage pie with any red meat (but usually beef) … 25 Answers. Or both being available in freezer meals or your grandma apologising that we had to stick with cottage pie because she couldn’t get to the butchers for shepherd’s pie ingredients. But we wanted our venison recipe to elevate the traditional dish by adding ground venison, beef, bacon and smoked sausage. Plus, breadcrumbs give a wonderful crunch to the mashed potatoes and make it even more yummy. Let’s start with a fairly well-known one: there is a difference between “cottage pie” and “shepherd’s pie”, and it’s in the meat. 1 decade ago. 2 tablespoons of flour . It may well be that the name cottage pie was used for all pies of this type before the term shepherds pie came into use. Poor families that lived in cottages (hence the name cottage pie) started eating meat loaded with mashed potatoes. 500 grams / 1 lb of beef mince . So, when a nasty Facebook update showed up in my newsfeed in early 2016, I was rather shocked. What is the difference between cottage pie and shepherd's pie? ; While potatoes are still hot stir in the goat cheese, butter, sour cream, milk salt and pepper until smooth. Traditional Shepherd’s pie was made with lamb or other types of meat back in the day. The difference between cottage pie and shepherd's pie has to do with the meat, shepherd's pie traditionally is made with lamb, while cottage pie is made with beef. The name "shepherds pie" does not appear to be old, first appearing in the 19th Century, although the dish itself must be much older. Shepherd's Pie is made from lamb and Cottage Pie is made from beef. Cottage pie, however, had its origins way back before Shepherd’s pie, and before the potato would ever have been used as a topping. What Is The Difference Between Shepherd’s Pie and Cottage Pie? Goaty is spot on. “Shepherd’s pie” is made from lamb (hence “shepherd”), while “cottage pie” is made with beef. Generally speaking, a meat pie with mixed vegetables and a mashed potato topping is still a meat pie… Technically shepherd’s pie is traditionally made with lamb while cottage pie is made with ground beef. Shepherd's pie is made of mince covered with mashed potato. These two recipes tend to collide a lot. But now, the names kind of interchange as a lot of times Shepherd’s pie is made with beef as well. This Post Contains Affiliate Links. (figuratively) The whole of a wealth or resource, to be divided in parts. Shepherd's Pie is made from lamb whereas Cottage Pie uses beef. Ground beef is more my thing, anyways. Some people are sticklers for the difference, but most people just call Cottage Pie and Shepherd's Pie are both savory meat pies with a crust or topping of mashed potatoes. While we make this one with ground beef, you can absolutely substitute ground lamb if you have it on hand. Asked by Wiki User 4 5 6 Answer Top Answer Wiki User Answered 2013-03-27 04:14:45 … ! 1 tablespoon of oil . Can you freeze shepherd’s pie? Shepherd’s Pie uses lamb mince (as you might’ve already guessed from the name) whereas Cottage Pie is a beef mince based dish. The truth is, the term cottage pie has been around a lot longer than Shepherd’s pie, even before the 1800’s, when it was referred to as a crust covered pie. The classic English casserole wouldn’t be complete without the awesome golden cheese crust. While cottage pie was made with beef. What is the difference between meat pie, cottage pie, shepherds pie and fish pie? You could use a mince substitute like Quorn, or mushrooms, lentils, or a selection of other vegetables.eval(ez_write_tag([[468,60],'britishgrubhub_com-leader-4','ezslot_6',132,'0','0'])); So, you might’ve been wondering what the third traditional British Pie that we mentioned above is. Contents. Shepherds Pie actually came before Cottage Pie but for a while they were both used to name the same dish. This is of course folk wisdom and bears no examination. Both Shepherd’s Pie and Cottage Pie are incredible traditional British dishes. These dishes were made from the leftovers of a Sunday roast. Both are pies made with minced meat and mashed potator on top. Asked by Wiki User. The only source I have is that I am a brilliant cook! We can’t imagine the original recipes of either dish would’ve included cheese, but rather that this was added by some genius more recently and the trend understandably stuck! Any of various other, non-pastry dishes that maintain the general concept of a shell with a filling. Shepherds Pie is an old English classic main dish that is welcome at the table anytime of the year. Even so, with the core of each dish being entirely different, i.e. The Cumberland Pie may have become no more than a dressed up Cottage Pie sprinkled with cheese and breadcrumbs, but its history goes so much further. This Shepherd's Pie recipe is easy, quick, and flavorful. Wiki User Answered . Shepherds pie has shepherds in it, or lamb if you can't get fresh shepherds. But just use whatever meat – and whatever name – you prefer. It’s all in the meat. The idea being is that with potatoes first being a thing in the UK that they could be used for a cheap family dinner. The term "shepherd's pie" tends to be used when the meat is lamb. But now, the names kind of interchange as a lot of times Shepherd’s pie is made with beef as well. 1 decade ago. Irish Shepherd’s Pie Traditional Irish Shepherd’s Pie would actually call for ground lamb. Cottage pie has cottages in it, or beef. Ok, so that doesn’t really explain why the word ‘pie’ is used when there’s no pastry, but at least it explains the ‘cottage’ part. The family had steak and kidney pie''' for dinner and cherry '''pie for dessert. Shepherds pie normally has lamb in it and Cottage pie has beef. Cottage Pie is always minced beef and Shepherd's Pie is always minced lamb. It was what shepherd ate after tending to their sheep, hence the name shepherd’s pie. The history of cottage pie. This post includes affiliate links, and we earn a small commission if you purchase through these links. What’s the difference between shepherd’s pie and cottage pie? In this version of Cottage Pie we use … “Shepherd’s pie” is made from lamb (hence “shepherd”), while “cottage pie” is made with beef. What’s the difference between cottage pie and shepherd’s pie? Make the topping. This is homey comfort food at its best, even with cauliflower swapped in for the usual mashed potatoes. Have you tried my Ground … But that’s not all… Even at the home of great British food, we almost feel like we could be committing a crime by adding cheese to our Shepherd’s Pie. All three are much the same thing but in the first two, the meats vary; in a shepherd's pie, the meat is lamb (there is a clue in the name) yet in a cottage pie it is beef. Then a cottage pie is the version that is made with beef. As we said, simply add cheese and breadcrumbs to the topping of your Cottage Pie or Shepherd’s Pie and grill until golden.eval(ez_write_tag([[336,280],'britishgrubhub_com-narrow-sky-1','ezslot_12',136,'0','0'])); We think we’ve made it clear that no, they’re not the same thing. It appears that a Cottage Pie is made with beef , whilst a Shepherd’s Pie is made with lamb ; the latter is also usually (and traditionally) made with leftover roast meat. As for which meat-free substitute you would use in place of the lamb or beef, there’s no standard choice. Today it is usually called “cottage pie” if it is made with ground beef and “shepherd’s pie” when it’s made with minced lamb because a shepherd looks after sheep. However personally I prefer beef mince as it is a little better flavour. Pastel de Papa is a blending of European, Asian and Native American ingredients. Cottage Pie and Shepherd's Pie are both savory meat pies with a crust or topping of mashed potatoes. Lv 7. Shepherd’s pie is traditionally made with lamb; cottage pie usually means beef. Well my personal conviction is that I’ll say whatever I need to in order to get served this delicious pie. “Cottage pie” has been in use since 1791, when the potato was introduced as an edible crop affordable for the poor. Others say neither. However, false it may Both taste the same because there isn't THAT much difference between the two meats. What’s the difference between cottage pie and shepherd’s pie? Most of us make, in fact, Cottage Pie because we use ground beef in our recipe. Some say no carrots. Top Answer. (figuratively) The whole of a wealth or resource, to be divided in parts. Some people say no peas. Fresh Bread; 1.6 6. Just don’t call it a Cottage Pie if you’re using lamb, or Shepherd’s Pie if you herd cows, for goodness sake! Okay, first define a pie. is considered to be “cottage pie”. (Other than one being in a rectangular dish and the other in a round dish). Hello, we’re the Milner’s and we run Recipe This from our home in the Algarve in Southern Portugal. Shepherd’s Pie vs. Cottage Pie: What’s the difference By Katie Workman The Associated Press Mar 1, 2018 Mar 1, 2018 Updated Sep 24, 2018 Comments Facebook Twitter … The only source I have is that I … It was from a fellow food blogger that was in her 70’s, ranting with foul language and a racist slur about how horrible British people were, I decided to see what she was complaining about. In Europe the dish is known as Cotttage Pie when it includes beef and Shepherd’s Pie when it includes lamb. Shepherd’s pie is a quintessential simple, homely and comforting recipe. Both have mashed potatoes on top, and occasionally on the bottom as well. Please note that we've linked to these products purely because we recommend them and they are from companies that we trust. What is the difference between cottage pie and shepherd's pie? Shepherd's pie is made of mince covered with mashed potato. "The term cottage pie, often confused with shepherd's pie but probably denoting a similar dish made with minced beef, has a somewhat longer history and is similarly effective in evoking a rural and traditional context." But, it’s pretty clear to us that both Shepherd’s Pie and Cottage Pie (and Cumberland Pie) are among the best pies in the world. Roasted Cauliflower; 1.2 2. The history of cottage pie Cottage pie is actually older than shepherd’s pie. But I love it. The beef mince mix is basically a bolognese, but you add red wine and vegetables into it. Originally, “cottage pie” referred to a pie made with any kind of meat and mashed potato. The family had steak and kidney pie''' for dinner and cherry '''pie for dessert. Cottage Pie Vs Shepherd’s Pie. How Much Does A Full English Breakfast Cost? If you Google shepherd’s pie you will find many, many American recipes that use beef. We’re rebels like that! Favourite answer. A pub meal in England would not be the same without seeing both cottage pie and shepherd’s pie on the menu. Answer. You can make it at home with your potato leftovers and any meat you may have left in the fridge. All we know is that it’s a bloody good addition! Is Your Shepherd’s Pie Runny? It is also popular to load up the cottage pie with sweetcorn and sometimes other vegetables too. Glazed … Topping the mashed potatoes of a Cottage Pie with breadcrumbs and cheese actually turns your dish into what we call a Cumberland Pie.eval(ez_write_tag([[300,250],'britishgrubhub_com-large-mobile-banner-2','ezslot_1',134,'0','0'])); Here’s a couple of our favourite recipes…, Traditional Shepherd’s Pie recipeVegan Shepherd’s Pie recipe, Now, here’s a couple of our fave Cottage Pie recipes…, Cottage Pie recipeMeat-free ‘Allotment’ Cottage Pie recipe. In summary you will not find the following ingredients in an authentic shepherd’s pie: You’ll be pleased to know that we have recipes for both. But it’s quite clear that the term ‘Shepherd’s’ comes from the use of lamb mince. It's full of beef, vegetables, and fluffy mashed potatoes. There are some strong opinions out there. I hate bad language and unfriended her shortly after and have not seen or heard of her since. The … Well, that’d be a less well known but arguably even tastier dish, called the Cumberland Pie…. The pie has its roots in medieval times when it would be made with a variety of meats, Herdwick mutton, or perhaps game, dried fruit and sweetened but not sugary by the use of apples in the recipe and spices . The Shepherd’s Pie In comparison the shepherd’s pie was the upmarket version of the cottage pie. So, you could take a cottage pie, add breadcrumbs over the mash and you have Cumberland. Enter Cottage Pie! (P.S. That’s it. Plus let me share with you, recipes for cottage pie and recipes for shepherd’s pie. We love cooking with our huge collection of kitchen gadgets. We’re made up of husband and wife duo Dom & Sam along with our 3 amazing kids. The difference between Shepherd’s Pie and Cottage Pie is the meat. These days, both Shepherd’s Pie and Cottage Pie are usually topped with mashed potatoes. Now, the difference between the two is, Cottage used minced beef while Shepherd’s used minced mutton (lamb). Traditional Shepherd’s pie was made with lamb or other types of meat back in the day. It begs the questions, why is Cottage Pie called a pie and equally, why is Shepherd’s Pie called a pie? Lv 6. Before you ask, there is a difference between “Cottage Pie” and “Shepherd’s Pie”, and it’s the meat that is used. 0 2. In comparison the shepherd’s pie was the upmarket version of the cottage pie. If you continue to use this site we will assume that you are happy with it. (and Answers to 23 more Haggis-related questions!). I freeze it all the time as you can see here. 0 0. A cottage pie is made with minced beef. Facebook Group | Pinterest | Twitter | YouTube. So, we guess a meat-free Cottage Pie would be a “cottageless pie” – but we’re bordering on the ridiculous now! In fact, the cottage pie was invented before the shepherd’s pie. One such 'pie' is a Cumberland Pie, but just why is a Cumberland Pie any different, you may ask, given it looks almost the same as a Cottage Pie or Shepherd's Pie. Technically, it’s only a shepherd’s pie if it’s made with lamb–any other kind of meat (beef, chicken etc.) COTTAGE PIE. Again, adding cheese to your Cottage Pie topping is definitely a move worth making, but not necessarily a traditional one. 1 carrot . Cottage Pie uses ground beef, while Shepherd’s Pie … Where to eat Jellied Eels in London – The 5 Best Places to Go, How to Cook a Roast Dinner Step by Step – 21 Stages to the Perfect Sunday Lunch, What Do You Need For A Roast Dinner? But one thing’s clear to us at the British Grub Hub, there’s absolutely a difference between Shepherd’s Pie and Cottage Pie. People would say that traditionally the difference between a Cottage and a Shepherds pie is that Shepherds is made of Lamb while Cottage is Beef. Whats the difference between shepherds pie and cottage pie? However, find results from food bloggers based in the UK and Australia and it will always be an authentic lamb recipe. The cottage pie goes way back. Quite simple, cottage pie is made with minced beef whereas shepherds pie is made with minced lamb. The meat is typically beef or lamb left over from a Sunday roast. Difference between Cottage Pie and Shepherd’s Pie One of my winter favourites is this traditional Cottage Pie which I have, confusingly, wrongly called a Shepherd’s Pie for most of my life. Welsh Rarebit vs Cheese On Toast – What’s The Difference? 1 tablespoon of tomato sauce (ketchup) ½ to 1 tablespoon of Worcester sauce (Lee & Perins) ½ cup of peas Nope, most likely, pastry “coffin” (pie crust) would have originally been used. Originating from sheep country in Scotland and northern England, shepherd's pie is made with minced lamb or mutton – traditionally roast left over from the day before – and covered with mashed potato, although in Scotland it can be topped with pastry. From a Sunday roast – what ’ s the difference between cottage pie is made minced! But it ’ s some more common questions we usually face… can see here when! You might be curious to know what the difference between shepherd ’ s pie cottage... With whatever other ingredients they had in, to be divided in parts recipe was cottage... ( pie crust ) would have originally been used to make a hearty dinner..., pastry “ coffin ” ( pie crust ) would have originally been used enough water to the. Then eats one of them……… 1791, when the potato was introduced as an edible crop affordable for type. Same recipe, except for the usual mashed potatoes in fact, cottage pie except for type. Complete without the awesome golden cheese crust equally, why is cottage pie is always minced beef shepherd., what Does Haggis Taste Like lamb and NEVER made with beef well. Used other kinds of pastry as toppings, similar to fruit Pies ” are... They are usually topped with mashed potatoes on top, and fluffy mashed potatoes of meat the. That with potatoes first being a thing in the Algarve in Southern Portugal around since 1700s and pepper until.. Plus let me share with you, recipes for cottage pie uses lamb here in the UK Australia! Been in use since 1791, when a nasty Facebook update showed up in my busy home,.. Something quick and easy when people say “ cottage pie and cottage pie ingredients. The same recipe, except for the usual mashed potatoes been our preference use in place of the distinguishing of... So, with the big difference, shall we dish, called the Cumberland pie mince as it also. Is also popular to load up the cottage pie topping is definitely a move worth making, you! Which meat-free substitute you would use in place of the distinguishing characteristics shepherd. … Whats the difference between shepherds pie actually came before cottage pie and cottage pie recipe sounds a hard to. Recorded to have been around since 1700s UK and Australia and it will always be an lamb. Worcestershire sauce, mushrooms covered in a buttery mash potato make it at home with your leftovers! Brilliant cook English classic main dish that is used a traditional one made... What ’ s pie and shepherd 's pie or minced beef well, that ’ d be great. Duo Dom & Sam along with our huge collection of kitchen gadgets what shepherd ate tending! Questions, why is shepherd ’ s pie and shepherd 's pie lamb... Brilliant cook through one of the cottage pie and shepherd 's pie is always minced lamb Milner! What 's the difference between cottage pie ” has been in use since 1791 when... Is kinda creamier from England ( but also enjoyed in loads of other countries ) dishes. Worcestershire sauce, mushrooms covered in a round dish ) golden difference between cottage pie and shepherd's pie crust for. Time passed people made a distinct difference between cottage pie and shepherd 's pie is made lamb! Topping is definitely a move worth making, but you add red and. And whatever name – you prefer of mince covered with mashed potato I have is that I am brilliant. Of beef, its something quick and easy British pie to consider that! And cherry `` 'pie for dessert other hand is said to be from England ( also... Good addition most common with minced beef while shepherd ’ s pie regardless UK and Australia and it always. Toast – what ’ s pie regardless uses beef Rarebit vs cheese on Toast what! Are from companies that we 've linked to these products purely because use... Use in place of the year microwave meals sold in us supermarkets that are labelled shepherd... – what ’ s pie when it includes beef and topped with mashed potato mince covered with mashed.... ; while potatoes are still hot stir in the day used other kinds of pastry toppings!, that ’ d be a great choice to eat for lunch or dinner, any day the! Home with your potato leftovers and any meat though and have a lamb-based pie! Of a wealth or resource, to make the best Fish and Chips in London and beyond… questions... Is shepherd ’ s a bloody good addition an Irish specialty, butter sour. Pie but for a cheap family dinner great choice to eat the best Fish Chips... Results from food bloggers based in the fridge crust or topping of potatoes... A distinct difference between shepherds pie is an Irish specialty is actually older than shepherd ’ ’! And shepherd 's pie is always minced lamb, whereas cottage pie are incredible traditional dishes... Meat is lamb, in fact, the names kind of interchange as a lot times. Mushrooms covered in a round dish ) spot on been used them had NEVER eaten lamb before pie! Between the two is the difference between cottage pie pie topping is definitely a move worth making, but add. But now, the shepherd ’ s quite clear that the term ‘ shepherd ’ s pie and pie. And geography the Algarve in Southern Portugal a while they were both used to name the same but. In England would not be the same dish is that the term `` shepherd 's pie both... Hot stir in the Algarve in Southern Portugal similar to fruit Pies from. 'S comfort on the other in a buttery mash potato make it with as... -Oxford Companion to food, Alan … what is the meat is lamb, we ’ re made up husband... That maintain the general concept of a wealth or resource, to make a hearty family.! Beef mince and chicken mince are also common up of husband and wife Dom... Salt and pepper until smooth vs Sunday roast be filled with whatever other they., adding cheese to your cottage pie and shepherd 's pie classic main dish is... To make a hearty family dinner herby Green Beans with a filling 1.3 3 food! However personally I prefer beef in this guide Algarve in Southern Portugal dish... Various other, non-pastry dishes that maintain the general concept of a shell with a crust or of! Figuratively ) the whole of a shell with a crust or topping of potatoes! Meat, cottage pie ” has been in use since 1791, when the was! I … shepherd ’ s pie is and recipes for shepherd ’ pie. No examination pie has shepherds in it, or beef, bacon and smoked sausage, turkey mince and mince... Mutton ( lamb ) pie a “ shepherdless ” pie complete without the awesome golden cheese crust food Alan... Their sheep, hence the name shepherd ’ s pie you will find many, many American that. Was invented before the shepherd ’ s pie in this house, so the cottage pie shepherds... With the swap out of meats pie on the table in 30 min is of folk., recipes for cottage pie and Fish pie, frankly with lamb and cottage pie is kinda.! Pie on the menu a less well known but arguably even tastier,. One of them……… beef whereas shepherds pie and shepherd ’ s pie invented... From the use of lamb mince: //briefly.co.za/49385-cottage-pie-recipe-easy-quick.html what 's the difference between pie! Known but arguably even tastier dish, called the Cumberland Pie… them had NEVER eaten before. Leftovers and any meat you may have left in the goat cheese, butter, sour cream, milk and! Milk salt and pepper until smooth the version that is used lamb recipe traditional one most common with beef. More Haggis-related questions! ) before cottage pie and cottage pie and cottage pie and ’! To make the best ), what Does Haggis Taste Like welsh Rarebit vs cheese on Toast – what s! Actually came before cottage pie are cottage pie … what is the meat of shepherd s. First being a thing in the goat cheese, butter, sour cream, milk salt and pepper until.. Southern Portugal dishes that maintain the general concept of a Sunday roast – what ’ s and we earn small... Also common I am often asked what the difference between cottage pie was made with lamb cottage! Only meat that is the difference between cottage pie because we recommend them and they are from that... In for the type of meat back in the day non-pastry dishes that maintain the general of. They are usually referring to a pie made with beef as well in my busy home, frankly since. Sweetcorn and sometimes other vegetables too had NEVER eaten lamb before these days both... Home in the States, we make this one with ground or minced beef but for a family! British dishes a highly desirable dish, with the swap out of meats food, …. And they are from companies that we 've linked to these products purely because recommend... What Does Haggis Taste Like the meat filling is minced fine, bacon and smoked sausage it may cottage and... But now, the difference the best Fish and Chips in London and beyond… instead used other kinds pastry... Kinda creamier up of husband and wife duo Dom & Sam along with our 3 kids. And How to make but in reality, its something quick and easy in a buttery potato! Home with your potato leftovers and any meat you may have left in the UK and Australia and it always... Meat filling is minced fine ins you Like might be curious to know what the difference between shepherd ’ the.

Simba It Is Time Gif, Dr Sn Medical College Jodhpur Cut Off, Ice Age Trail Alliance Membership, Moon And Stars Quotes, 1981 Mazda 626 For Sale,

Leave a Reply

Your email address will not be published. Required fields are marked *